Thursday, 5 February 2026

Battle of Paoli September 1777 : plus lots of other stuff

I seem to be busy on other stuff so posting less often which means a bumper catch-up this week.

First up the next instalment of our AWI campaign, after the battle of the clouds General Wayne has pulled back his force. They are encamped in a wooded area close to the Warren Tavern in Chester county. The British under General Grey carry out a night attack. Historically this was a chaotic engagement in which the British were accused of carrying out some brutal murders of surrendering troops, giving rise to the name of the battle the Massacre of Paoli.

This map gives the overall position of the British advance
A more fun period map of the engagement
Our scenario once again for R&P starts at the point when the British have driven off the Northern pickets, so the alarm has been raised and the Americans have formed up to escape. The American still have three pickets to the south as shown. The Americans must try and get 50% or more of their army off the table to the left. All ranges reduced to 12” as it is dark. Part form their skirmishers and light troops the British, will have to stop and load as they went into the combat with unloaded muskets to avoid alarming the Americans. The British are veterans and aggressive as they have their bayonets already fixed . The cannon blocking the exit in the fence must be activated on a reducing D6 to open the gap (this blockage occurred historically causing some of the American confusion). To give some variety the British will arrive randomly from the three location shown rather than all in the centre.

The alarm raised in the camp as the meridians prepare to exit left ?
The British flood on and their light infantry chose to open fire, other infantry moves forward to assault the stragglers in the camp
Some of the american pickets are brought back to try and hold the British advance, the cannon is starting to move after turn 3, but some of the Americans in the rear are now isolated
Three units of american infantry find themselves separated in the camp, they are brutally dealt with in hand to hand combat.
The camp now nearly clear but the rest of the Americans are being chased out of the camp.
Unfortunately for the British their commander General Grey advances from the Tavern and makes slow progress, with his troops unable to shoot he advances only for them to be surprised by and temporarily thrown back by some American pickets.
Having despatched the last units in the camp the chase continues but now the Americans have the advantage as the British don’t have time to load their muskets
Hot foot the Americans make their escape
The final British shots ring out into the darkness but the Americans have managed to escape with about 2/3 of their force. So ultimately a win for the Americans given the victory conditions we had set. A fun battle and As always the battle felt close and tense right up to the last couple of turns and there was certainly no guarantee the American would get enough troops off the table. The British failed a couple of key activations and it didn’t help with two units coming on around the tavern which was too far away to impact the battle. 

I have been painting and prepping lots of stuff but the only finished unit is the last ! Of my french Curassiers, these were a slightly mixed group left over, some of which needed repainting but the unit has come out ok, I think I need a French cavalry parade ?

Other games in the last week or so, I met anther wargamer through George who invited me down for an ECW game, a beautiful collection. Using his house rules we played through the Battle of Adwalton Moor.
Beautiful collection of ECW in 28mm but. Tough battle for the Parliamentarians who are heavily outnumbered.
We did make a good fist of it though and nearly chased off the Royalist infantry, we’re just planning a return trip up to the dungeon, and I have a few possible ideas to adapt our KoW rules?

Last weekend we had our annual shopping trip to York wargame show ‘Vapnartak’, actually I didn’t want to buy much as I have a lot in the various lead and plastic piles already but the bring and buy is always fun. The show was noticeable reduced in terms of traders with quite a few spaces and a further reduction in games on display. But there were plenty of punters and it was busy right up to when we left around 14:00
What looks like random stuff but all super bargains from the B&B. Yes I now have a Tirpitz to make in 1/350 scale it is over twice the length of the destroyer I blogged a couple of months ago !!!! The only disappointment was the green American truck which I thought was a WW2 artillery transporter, but on closer inspection when I got it home it turns out it is probably an M8 artillery tractor from around 1950, so too much of a stretch to squeeze it into Sicily. If anyone can think of a use let me know. It came with the two halftracks for next to nothing anyway. The packets contain 1/3000 WW1 ships and I have been putting together a small force for. Few games later in the year.

Finally for this post this morning I was down to George’s to continue (finish) or early war French campaign. Once again a beautiful table setup, one of the most complex battlefields in the campaign book. Germans on the attack again, loads of cover. George I’m sure will cover the battle in more detail.
The Germans took their time deploying in cover in the woods and moving up to take the station, after some exchange of fire on the German left the french started to pull back.
But Gaston a local Nazi sympathiser was behind them and started taking pot shots with his shotgun ! Whilst the french tried to deal with him.
The German panzer IV got lucky hitting the french tank as it rumbled down the road. The tanks actually exchanged several shots but it was the Germans who rolled lucky and got the decisive hit. Actually I was pretty lucky the whole battle with multiple double turns and loads of 5/6’s when I needed them. At this point the french decide the battle was up and the Germans would inevitably break through to win the campaign.

A great campaign with several difficult battles for both sides, perhaps the Germans have the edge but then they are attacking most of the time which is generally harder, looking forward to our next campaign ?

So certainly keeping busy and likely an ACW battle on Saturday, and I now have the Tirpitz to make 😂

Thanks as always for taking the time to check what I’ve been upto.

Matt ❤️




34 comments:

  1. You have been busy, Matt! Some great looking games on show! Your Curassiers look fab too!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have read a bit about Paoli but never thought it would make much of a game, but it just shows how just about anything can in the hands of someone who knows what they are doing. Lovely stuff and the ECW game looks great. I'll be keen to see your completed WWI ship collection emerge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lawrence, the game worked out ok I’m not sure i would admit to knowing what I’m doing 🙂 the little ships will make an appearance in the future

      Delete
  3. Matt, you remain very, very busy, indeed! Your Paoli scenario was a good one and gave the Americans a chance. Had all of your British rushed right up the middle, I am not sure any American could have survived. Your charges into hand-to-hand combat were devastating every single time. I was able to trade space for time in a classic fighting withdrawal. Good fun!

    That ECW game looks great! Like your friend, I enjoy having a 28mm ECW collection, but your EPIC scale collection looks fab. What rules were you fellas using for this game?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon, 28mm vs 15mm a good debate for the future. Rules were house rules not sure their origin but heavily adapted

      Delete
  4. Oh my! What a fantastic looking games Matt!

    ReplyDelete
  5. The traitorous dog is in the French annals as Guiseppe, I am sure the truth will come out in '45. Well done, a good number of games and great fun. I’ll give it some thought for the next one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. False identity papers I suspect you have to be careful working for the Germans in 1940 ! Open to options for the next one 👍

      Delete
  6. As I read the description of your battle, Matt, I realized it was one I did myself as a solo...the Americans were dealt to more severely in my version, but then, I didn't have to adjust it to make it fair for a second player!
    The inevitable conclusion of the France 1940 campaign ...I remember you had a couple of hard slogs earlier on, so it wasn't one sided by any means.
    ECW and cuirassiers look superb!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Keith Paoli makes and interesting skirmish, best played as part of a bigger campaign in my view as in isolation the ‘escape’ objective for the Americans is a bit odd. The CoC campaign was a lot of fun and playing with George’s collections a treat 👍

      Delete
  7. Really enjoyed the report on your AWI game with Jon. Looking foward to the next one.

    The other games, ECW and WW2 were likewise visual treats and looked really interesting.

    Have fun building that battleship. I've just finished listening to the "We Have Ways of Making You Talk" podcast series on the Bismarck, Tirpitz' sister ship and was thoroughly drawn in. (very much worth a listen if you have time and inclination)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dai, luckily the ship is a fairly easy model, I’ll try and find that podcast this afternoon.

      Delete
    2. It's well worth listening to. Although you need a lot of time for all 4 episodes.

      Delete
  8. What a marvellous mixed-bag in this post Matt!
    As always, your games are an absolute delight to view (and interesting actions to boot). Those two at George's are equally lovely.
    I thought that I was a bit crazy going for 1/700—is the 1/350 Tirpitz destined for the table top or the shelf?
    A French cavalry parade sounds like a must.
    Best wishes, James

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks James, the Tirpitz is definitely heading for the sea I think a bombing missing is in order ? I might get the cavalry out this afternoon while setting up the ACW

      Delete
  9. You've been busy with a couple of excellent games. I like the look of those French cuirassiers

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very kind Neil the Curassiers aren’t my best but if they muster at the back they will be fine.

      Delete
  10. A wonderful pot pourri post there Matt:)! Shame the British arrival near the tavern was too far away to have a meaningful impact on the game, but it helped make for a more balanced game. Great work on the French and two lovely FtF games too. As for the M8 artillery tractor, I'd just use it as is and not sweat it too much, but then I'm a shallow cove;). I've not heard anything about the Vapnartak show, but a tad worrying about reduced traders and games, but something that has been going on for many a year now:(.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve, whilst I try to keep as many elements of the historical battle sometimes they need a little tweek to give them some balance and to make them ‘interesting’ from both sides. I’m certainly not a sticker for buttons but using the tractor may be pushing it ? I’m sure I can find somebody who wants it ?

      Delete
  11. Three very fine looking battles on show there Matt as well as your nicely painted French cavalry. Do you think Vapnartak is on the slide now as well? Phil and I gave up on it pre Covid I think, at the wrong time of the year to enjoy York.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks David fun games all, as for Vapnartak I’m not sure, whilst there were less traders and games on show there were plenty of punters, I guess as soon as those numbers drop it might be a challenge assuming the racecourse is on the expensive side ?

      Delete
    2. For those interested, there is a lively discussion on the SoA forum discussing whether or not Vapnartak is in retreat.

      Delete
  12. Hi Matt, loved the look of the AWI game and immediately thought that it would make a good game to take to a show. Then I saw your other two games and couldn’t decide which I liked best!

    Your comment about Vapnartak really interested me. I feel that small and middle size shows have been losing traders for a while, but always thought there was a top tier of shows that are actually growing (such as partizan has significantly grown since Covid) and I would have put Vapnartak in that safety net of top tier.

    It will be interesting to see how Hammerhead and the two partizans do this year (and Salute) by contrast.

    Vapnartak does of course have its own identity, it is the first show of the year and the trader element has always seemed to have a bigger emphasis than the gaming tables i.e. it is a buying show and maybe the dynamic of pressure on domestics budgets means this show is more vulnerable than the shows with a more even balance. Certainly a thing to watch with interest. I hope it is a temporary, one off dip.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Norm, obviously I can only take credit for the AWI battle the others hosted by Erik and George. As for Vapnartak we enjoy it as a day trip out and especially the bring and buy. The reduction in games has been notable over the last couple of years. It would be a significant shame to lose one of the bigger shows up North, but times change.

      Delete
  13. Couple of great battles. See you in a couple of weeks to put those cuirassiers to the sword

    ReplyDelete
  14. Great post Matt. Something in there for everyone. Loved your scenery for Paoli, and the two games at George's.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris, I guess it shows my wargaming has some variety 🤔

      Delete
  15. Wow, great looking games Matt, superb tables...and cuirs!

    ReplyDelete