We are upto September 1777 in our AWI campaign so some big battles to play over the next few months. Having read up quite a bit on Brandywine I decided to break it into three separate scenarios. It is quite a hard battle to break down as the danger is you create scenarios which are unbalanced. Anyway after a lot of ‘thinking’ we just got on with it.
The overall battle of Brandywine, generally regarded the largest battle in the AWI. The three separate scenarios are shown roughly in green. First up the Battle for Chads Ford.
This is a really tough one as historically Knyphausen was only ever ordered to demonstrate and tie down the Rebels so that Cornwallis could carry out his long flanking march north. As the British are hugely outnumbered we have tried to create some balance. I have assumed that some of the American forces have already been drawn away to hold the flank leaving three American brigades under Sullivan to hold Chad’s and Briton’s Fords. I also set the Americans back a bit.
The American defenders
The British/Hessian attackers
The American line along the high ground set back from the river, they will need to move forward or wait until the British start to cross ?
They chose to move forward, but open up with their artillery cleverly situated along the roads, the Americans do have one unit of light infantry positioned in the woods by the river
The British advance towards Brintons Ford, the light infantry in the foreground have already been driven back !
Great force, two brigades heading for Chads Ford
British artillery opens up to support the attack
The Riflemen (Green clad) open up an effective fire
Wet feet for the leading British infantry, but they come under tremendous fire from the defenders
Some of the Americans hold their fire whilst the militia are pushed forward !
Hessians approaching Chads Ford
And push over the river in the face of the enemy
Things are looking hopeful at Brinton’s Ford as well ?
The defenders use the Hesssians as target practice 🙁
But despite massive losses the lead unit holds while others come up behind
A critical point with the fords breached all that need ps to happen is the follow up units to rush across…….You’ve got to be kidding snake eyes and the lead units retreats!
The British are over too but have less support
….and can’t get enough troops to the Ford
Suddenly at Chad’s Ford there is a glimmer of light, the light infantry is driven back and two other defending units are wiped out, morale checks cause some of the defenders to waver a bit
The British now have the numbers
Still putting pressure on at Brintons Ford
And some of the defenders here see the writing on the wall and are forced back
Sullivan is looking nervous as his line thins all that remains is for the rallied Hessian unit to rush across the Ford !
NO WAY ! The same b….y unit and another snake eyes 🤬
The hessians do eventually get across the Ford, but the Americans somehow find some reserves who are brought up into the line
At Brintons Ford the river must be running red as the attackers have been pretty much wiped out. At this point we called it a day, after all the main battle is actually taking place about a mile to the NE where Cornwallis has caught Washington in the flank.
A fun battle very tough for Knyphausen to make progress and a lot of blood was spilt trying to force the crossings. The Americans were put under a lot of pressure and there really was a point where Chads Ford looked like it was going to fall. In hindsight I might change a couple of things in the scenario. We considered a clever rule to force the Americans to gradually draw off more troops as they did historically, one other option might be to force some of the Americans to start closer to the river where they would almost certainly have been destroyed by the advancing British. Possibly the Artillery was more effective than we had expected but this worked for both sides so balanced out. Looking forward to Birmingham Hill the British attacking again but this time they outnumber the Rebels.
These ‘Rangers’ had languished partly painted for several years but as I needed them to play as Riflemen they got completed. One thing I have noticed is that I am much quicker at painting now than 10 years ago.
The British also needed another artillery piece, and this was in the leadpile waiting.
That’s it for now two more games in the diary where we will be seeing the ACW collection on the table.
Then we are off on holiday the last couple of weeks in March. A slightly long story but we are visiting the Old Colonial lands of America and the trip will most likely involve visiting lots of historical sights and battlefields. Weather dependant I’m hoping to get to (not in order) Gettysburg, Princeton, Trenton, Brandywine, valley forge, Germantown, Monocacy and probably a bunch of other museums and historical locations.
Thanks as always for checking by
Matt❤️
Great looking game. Good luck on your trip, may you get good weather.
ReplyDeleteThanks Joe hoping for no snow and the less rain the better ?
DeleteWell-planned and beautifully presented game, Matt! In retrospect, the American artillery was simply too dominating of the approaches to the two fords. Without these guns, I am not so sure the Colonials would have had much of a chance to stop the British.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jon be nice if the Rebels failed an activation with those cannons sometime ? Ok you had a few …….but not so many. A splendid game whatever the outcome 😀 again in hindsight the troops at the Ford should probably have had cover which might have reduced the effectiveness of the artillery but I happy that there was at least a glimmer of a chance for the British !
DeleteAnother nice battle. See you next week
ReplyDeleteThanks 👍
DeleteThat would be a very hard battle for the Crown forces Matt....I think your idea about gradually reducing the number of defenders is a good one...a bit like reinforcements coming at staggered turns...but in reverse!
ReplyDeleteNew units look very nice and acquitted themselves well in the game, and the upcoming holiday sounds like it will be excellent and filled with blog post opportunities.
Thanks Keith , as you say it was always going to be tough for the ‘good guys’ but we gave it a try, and certainly tied down the Rebels for a good while
DeleteGreat looking game Matt. Hard fought , looking forward to seeing the other 2 scenarios
ReplyDeleteThanks Neil 👍
DeleteSuperb looking game Matt, top notch table and figures and a good read too, can't get much better than that.
ReplyDeleteVery kind Donnie glad you enjoyed it 👍
DeleteAnother lovely looking game Matt!
ReplyDeleteThanks Michal 👍
DeleteA fine game and report. Strange your painting has speed up, mine has slowed with age👴🏻 Enjoy your trip, I've done Gettysburg three times and would go again, if only...
ReplyDeleteThanks David…certainly looking forward to Gettysburg amongst others 👍
DeleteThe scenario didn't come across as being too unbalanced and, as you say, perhaps a minor tweak here and there would even it up nicely. Of course, the double ones on two occasions wouldn't have helped.
ReplyDeleteThanks Lawrence, we have learnt that using these rules it is hard to attack where you need to move and fire when the defender can stand and shoot, proportionally they get greater fire power so unless you can overwhelm them or hide it is tough. But we enjoyed the game and there was certainly a glimmer for a while. The double ones and the American reinforcements really didn’t help 🙁
DeleteMatt - great game report and a battle I'm working up to (painting up to!). On the trip that will be great fun. You will probably need to think about how best to get over Brandywine and Germantown as it isn't always obvious where the battlefield is! Monmouth Courthouse was (surprisingly?) exceptional and whilst i appreciate you can only get to so many places i would put Antietam right up there (Bull Run not far behind); our guide was top notch; I can still get shivers thinking about Bloody Lane and the Cornfield. Andrew
ReplyDeleteAndrew thanks for taking the time to comment hopefully the rest of the battle will feature in the next few months, and good luck with the painting 👍 and thanks for your advice re Monmouth, sadly I think it is just one battlefield too far as I’m heading west not east from Philadelphia. I’m fortunate that this isn’t my first visit to ACW battlefields and completely agree Antietam is right up there as one of the best I managed to spend two days there a few years ago. I have also been to Manassas but am hoping I might fool my wife into a short visit this trip. Montmouth my give me a reason to go back another year ?
DeleteA splendid game with a fine pictorial and worded narrative to carry one along with the action. Have a good trip and may the weather gods favour you more than the dice gods.
ReplyDeleteThanks Phil, I’m glad it at least looks like my rambling is planned 🙂
DeleteFantastic looking game Matt and an engrossing report. There were chances for both sides, it seemed. Clearly the Hessian mercenaries really did not have their hearts in it! :)
ReplyDeleteI think that I may be getting quicker at painting than in the past (couldn't be much slower!). Are we more pragmatic when we realised that the time is limited?!
All the best for your trip. Sounds beaut.
Regards, James
Thanks James, very disappointed with the Hessians, they had victory in their hands and fled instead ! Painting speed I think I just fiddle less and can get to a gamble standard much quicker?
DeleteYour AWI games re really a joy to look at.
ReplyDelete😁
Thanks Stew happy to share 👍
DeleteLovely table Matt, catch up when you get back, enjoy.
ReplyDeleteThanks George 👍
DeleteA great game and good post-game thoughts too Matt. The new units look great and I too think my glacial painting speed is faster than of old, as I don't worry to much about getting all the detail right, as they disappear on the table. Lucky you going to visit some of the battlefields! Feeling rather jealous now...
ReplyDeleteThanks Steve a fun game. Looking forward to our trip now 👍
DeleteGreat looking troops, great looking game, wargaming at its finest!
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Ray 👍
DeleteGreat looking game, same old story, British attack, Americans sit back and shoot, British loss, still, sounds like fun, new figures look good, I'm definately a faster painter than ten years ago, I'ts a conscious decision to keep refining in order to make the process faster!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
Marvellous stuff Matt…
ReplyDeleteA great looking game indeed…
You trip sound like it will be fun… and possible tiring 🤣
All the best. Aly