Tuesday, 24 October 2023

The Battle of Torgau 1760 : SYW

Finally feeling well enough to get a battle in so Martin came over for a run out with our SYW collection. Believe it or not we are at the end of my SYW scenario book with the Battle of Torgau. (Not Torbay as the spellchecker keeps wanted to change it to !) the battle took place on the 3 November 1760. After the battle of Liegnitz the Prussians and Austrians had manoeuvred around Silesia for a couple of months. Eventually Fredrick closed on the Austrians under the redoubtable Daun close to the Fortress city of Torgau.

The Austrian main army was on the plateau in a strong defensive position with artillery support from around the City itself. Rather than a frontal assault Fredrick once again split his army taking about half of his force through the forests to assault the Austrians from the rear. The Austrians  got wind of this and were able to adjust their position to be attacked from both sides.

Historically it was a very tough fight and although the Prussians eventually forced the Austrians to retire it cost Frederick over a third of his army and I believe he would never again assault a prepared Austrian position.

As usual a map of the battlefield from the internet, the red area roughly our battlefield
Converted to a 8x5 table. The Prussians to the right although on the table will have a random delayed arrival as they march through the woods to the battlefield. A couple of other adjustments, the Austrians have a battery of heavy artillery outside Torgau and we agreed these could fire without actually being able to see targets. The stream/river a key feature of the battle field would force a test for each regiment looking to cross as they search for less marshy areas to cross.
Lacy’s corps. advance to the sound of the guns from their positions around Torgau
Prussian Cavalry move through Siptiz (spelt several different ways) to hold the bridge 
These are countered by General Zeschwitz cavalry division
The Prussian cavalry have arrived to the north through Weslau.
The rest of the Austrian surge forward but there is still no sign of the Prussians from the north. I should mention here that the largest Division under General Buelow rolled a six first turn and immediately arrived on the battle field around Weslau. They then managed to roll 1’s three turns in a row and failed to activate. This was a major disadvantage for the Prussians.
The Prussian to the south attempt to cross the river and open fire on the main Austrian army, Prussian Hussars can be seen in the distance cross by the bridge
With the delayed piecemeal arrival of the Prussian infantry from the north, the hot headed Prussian cavalry who have charged and scattered the Austrian cavalry in the centre, find themselves caught isolated beyond the village of Weslau
They are forced to retreat, past the Prussian infantry who just stand immobile !!!!!!!!
I forgot to take many photos at the west end of the battlefield where some Prussians have now arrived these chatty the defending Austrians from both sides and start to clear that end of the plateau.
Lacy’s Corps is now starting to deploy to block the narrow gap at this end of the plateau 
A better shot of the situation to the west, although the Prussian cavalry has been forced back this end of the plateau has been nearly cleared
Finally General Buelow gets his division moving and these are supported by Grenadiers under General Markgraf and Frederick himself these are able to retake the village of Weslau
But with the Prussian cavalry blown, the Austrians have managed to reform their cavalry on the plateau and Lacy’s Corps is now in position
The Prussians have taken about half of the plateau but their attack is stalled. In the very top right of this picture you can see General Huelsen’s Division which repeatedly failed to arrive through the woods, in the end failing to roll a 2 !
And then catastrophe Buelow’s Division falls below half strength and collapses leaving the village of Weslau in Austrian hands again
At this point it was clear it was an Austrian victory, the Prussians still have forces on the table but are not in a position to force the Austrians to withdraw. The Austrians have maintained their cavalry and have a strong defensive position across the narrow part of the plateau. A really splendid battle which was very closely fought, had it not been for the delayed arrival of the Prussian infantry and ultimately the collapse of Buelow’s division it might have been a different result.

As an aside, those very eagle eyed amongst you may have noticed this is the first run out for a new base cloth. I picked up two cloths from Dunelm when they had a sale and have stitched them together prior to some spraying with acrylic cans. This gives me a single much larger cloth which can also be used to cover my 12x6 table when we play in the garden. It is also slightly lighter in colour which is better for the photos. The key thing is it makes arrangement of hills easier.
As the battlefield was set up the evening before I took the opportunity to see what the epic ECW figures looked like on what is technically 10mm terrain
Very happy with this look, so other than possibly picking up a handful of 10mm buildings appropriate to ECW I don’t need anything different, my 15mm hedges should work fine as well.

Thanks as always for checking by 🙂

Matt



40 comments:

  1. First, it is great to see you well enough to return to the gaming table.
    Second, you continue setting a superb looking table. Your new cloth fits in well with your figures and bases. Terrain too!
    Finally, having neither studied nor gamed Torgau, I am struck by the similarity to the Russian defensive position at Kunsersdorf.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon….just about well but health still improving. I’m not sure many would actually have noticed the change in cloth but it helps with the photos. From what I know of Kunnersdorf the Russian were more seriously dug in whilst the Austrians didn’t have the opportunity. I think what strikes me is how foolish it would be to attack a prepared position without significant numerical advantage. I think many of these commanders were over confident and frequently just rode their luck ?

      Delete
  2. Looks like a fantastic game, terrain and figures great as always. Glad you're feeling better.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks John health is at least still improving 👍

      Delete
  3. Good to see you up and running again, the scope of the 10mm game is magnificent.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Was a great game, a close run thing - thought I'd blown it at one point. The new cloth looks great, I bought a couple at BM bargains that I need to stitch together

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Martin …..if only the reserves had activated earlier I think it might have been different.

      Delete
  5. I second Jonathan's sentiments on your recovery. I was made aware of Torgau "back in the day" when I purchased the GDW game on this battle (worth checking out if you can find it--way ahead of its time, with grand tactical mechanics before anyone else was doing them). I was also struck with how similar the problems of coordinating the Prussian approach in tge GDW game seem to have come out in your replay. Lovely looking game and engaging report: thanks for posting!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. GDW's Torgau is a good one? I still see it on ebay regularly. Perhaps I ought to add it to the collection.

      Delete
    2. Thanks Ed, I’m not aware of the game you mention, one thing I have been considering playing some of these battles but with smaller units but on a larger table to give an even greater sense of manoeuvre and space.

      Delete
  6. Great battle report. I also like the look of the gaming cloth

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Neil the cloth is of course multipurpose so we will be seeing it again

      Delete
  7. That looked like a tough nut to crack so an Austrian victory is not a surprise. I'm trudging through the second volume of Michael Leggiere's book on 1813 campaign and the Torgau plateau makes an appearance there as well. The Epic figures are 12mm from memory so 15mm hedges should work well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The delay to the Prussian reserves was a big disadvantage to overcome, that said the Prussians still put in a good fight. Torgau take two I might look that one up ?

      Delete
    2. I don't think it was actually a battle, but featured in the back and forth maneuverings in 1813.

      Delete
  8. Very nice Matt, glad to see you back to normal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks George almost back to normal……🤔

      Delete
  9. Nice new mat Matt! The little chaps and their even smaller chums look good on it! Glad you are well enough to resume gaming.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks David, I’m happy with the effect of the new mat and it is very flexible for creating different terrain which is what I need 👍

      Delete
  10. Good to hesr you're up to gaming, lovely looking table, close run battles are always fun and your 13.5mm ECW types look great on your existing terrain I think , oh and nice cloth!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain, I am certainly happy with the new cloth and looking forward to getting the ECW into battle but it is going to be some time 👍

      Delete
  11. What a great looking and sounding game Matt - the random arrival of the Prussians is a great way to add some friction into the scenario and then the dice helped out too - sorry but I would always favour Austrians over Prussians regardless of the era! The quick photo shoot with the new Epic ECW figures at the end looks very nice too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Keith………not sure I favour either side although the Prussians are a bit more colourful.🙂

      Delete
  12. Looked a fab game Matt, the mat and terrain look brilliant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ray . The cloth was very cheap given the size and effect so happy with the end result 👍

      Delete
  13. A splendid looking game Matt…
    The terrain looks lovely…I must pop into Dunelm myself and see what they have…

    All the best. Aly

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Aly…certainly worth a trip….I managed to get these in a sale so we’re particularly cheap which helps, the three spray tins were actually more expensive than the two cloths !

      Delete
  14. Looking grand , sounds like you had a great game

    ReplyDelete
  15. Great to see you well enough to get a game in Matt and fingers crossed you continue to recover. The SYW game looks superb and your new matt works a treat. Nice to see the ECW figures en parade as it were.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great looking game Matt, nice to see all the toys on the table. Looks like a great game to play in.
    Cheers
    Stu

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great way to run this battle Matt. I played it straight from the maps in Duffy's books (I can be unimaginative like that!). Interesting that Lawrence mentions the plateau cropping up in the 1813 campaign. It was also the scene of the Combat of Zinna in 1759 where the fight occurred at the eastern end of the plateau. Also Fritz attacked a prepared Austrian position 2 years later at Burkersdorf in a more Napoleonic style (and succeeded). Accounts of both actions can be found in Kronoskaf.
    PS love the new cloth.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris….I will seek out the Burkersdorf battle at some point. The challenge with all historical gaming is getting the balance between a recreation and a balanced but entertaining battle. Sometimes it works and sometimes not. For this series of SYW battles we have tended to stick to ‘fairly’ historical setups. I will return to a number of these battles with some more open setups.

      Delete